One Response to “Catherine Banner billed as the "new" JK Rowling”

August 3rd, 2008 at 12:41 pm
Oli says:

Open Quote

Don’t waste your time or your money on this book. It’s poorly written, with the exception of a few clumsy lunges in the direction of lyricism; and it lacks the vital ingredient that all great fantasy requires: good storytelling. This is probably because there is little story to tell. Characterisation is virtually non-existent, and the characters leave you feeling cold. Nothing. There is no great conflict or action and, as a result, no real story. Take my advice and invest in a few David Gemmell novels instead, or some Weis and Hickman.

In a word, this book was unpickupable.

Closing Quote

Leave a Reply

Polls

Who is (or will be) the greatest fantasy author of all time?

View Results

Categories

Archive