The Soddit by Adam Roberts

The Soddit book cover
Rating 4.0/10
At least it's not as bad as Barry Trotter.

Review by Cat Fitzpatrick

Bingo Sac Grabbins is asked by the coughing wizard Gandef and some (oddly Welsh) dwarves to help them relieve the great dragon Smug of his gold.

We’re going all the way back to 2003 with this stocking-filler spoof of The Hobbit, written by novelist and parodist, Adam Roberts. Paradoxically it’s a sequel to Bored of the Rings, a parody of Lord of the Rings, which is itself a sequel to The Hobbit. Whatever it is, both books were cashing in on the LOTR mania that still is sweeping the land as two Hobbit films hove into view, so we may see this little gem reappear on the counter of Waterstones next Christmas.

Like the Barry Trotter series of parodies by Michael Gerber, the basic idea is to take the names of the original characters and just change them slightly to appear funny, so Bilbo Baggins is Bingo Grabbings, Gandalf is Gandef and Smaug is Smug. We then run through the Hobbit’s story with people falling over things, Gandef being a deaf old man, and various other slapstick goings on.

As you probably expect, this is a mildly amusing top-up gift for fans of LOTR, which holds no interest for people who don’t know the books, and limited interest for those that do. Basically, these books are a one-trick pony that may amuse until the end of Boxing Day. It sounds harsh for what is really an inoffensive comedy gift, but really there was very little point to this apart from to make some money. However, anybody picking this up can get that from looking at the cover so maybe we’re all to blame. At least it’s not as bad as Barry Trotter.

Purchase options

Paperback/hardback (Amazon)
Flag of the UK. Flag of the US.

Kindle ebook (Amazon)
Flag of the UK. Flag of the UK.

You Say

What did you think about The Soddit?
Submit your own reader review and award the book the rating you think it deserves.

First name
Your review
Country where you live
Book
Your rating (out of 10)
Books of the Month: June 2013

Four books - old and new alike - that were a joy to read are selected each month. See past winners.

Image derived from The Sacred Band book cover.The Sacred Band
David Anthony Durham
Image derived from the No Return book cover.No Return
Zachary Jernigan
Image derived from the NOS4R2 book cover.NOS4R2
Joe Hill
Image derived from the Zoo City book cover.Avilion
Robert Holdstock

Collage of 3 fantasy book book covers.Fantasy series we recommend

You may also like...

Mogworld

Mogworld

Yahtzee Croshaw

8.7
Shadowmagic

Shadowmagic

John Lenahan

8.5