The Gift by Alison Croggon

The Gift book cover logo logo
Rating 7.3/10
This is a real gem of a book which deserves to be read by more.

When my girlfriend informed me that I would be reading Alison Croggon’s ‘The Gift’ and subsequent sequels, and would enjoy it, I found myself under a modicum of pressure. What if I weren’t to like it? What if Croggon has the same writing abilities as a cockroach named Paolini (was that too low?). I was a little worried, and the first part of the book didn’t engender me with much confidence.

Thankfully, at the completion of Croggon’s first book in her Pellinor quartet, I can sit here and say that I really rather enjoyed it.

Alison Croggon, a Melbournite like myself, has created a world that – akin to Janny Wurts’ The Wars of Light and Shadow – puts the focus away from simple stereotypical hero-ing. The Gift introduces us to the land of Edil-Amarandh, where Bards are the practitioners of magic and music is the ultimate expression of their talents.

The story focuses on Maerad, a 16 year old slave who is rescued by one of the lands greatest Bards, Cadvan. However it doesn’t take long for Cadvan to realize that Maerad is not just the untrained Bard he had thought he had found, but rather the fulfilment of a long forgotten prophecy.

There isn’t much with which I can find fault with in this book. Croggon does have a tendency to revert to the thesaurus a little too much, but there are those who enjoy the continuing revolution of words.

I mentioned in the intro that the “first part of the book didn’t engender me with much confidence.” Croggon splits The Gift into four “parts”, to help distinguish the storytelling. The first part is smaller than the rest, but also seems very rushed. It appears that Croggon didn’t want to really tell that part of the story, and just wanted to get Maerad to one of the School’s as fast as possible.

And sadly, there are some instances where comparisons to Lord of the Rings are a little too loud too ignore. Thankfully, however, the rest of the book does hold up on its own.

One particular aspect of the book which has provided a great deal of joy to me (and to my girlfriend, the linguistics fanatic) is Croggon’s attention to the language within the book. Unlike some books (which I won’t name, but you can probably guess at), Croggon has actually put a lot of work into the language of the story, and is warranted the small appendices she has at the back to explain. A definite Welsh-ness exudes from the names on the page, and adds great depth to the story that might have otherwise not existed in such quantities.

This is a real gem of a book which deserves to be read by more, and I’m really excited about reading the following three books. Whether your an Australian or just a lover of good fantasy, The Gift by Alison Croggon is definitely a book for you.

This The Gift book review was written by

All reviews for: The Books of Pellinor

Have you read The Gift?

We've found that while readers like to know what we think of a book they find additional reader reviews a massive help in deciding if it is the right book for them. So if you have a spare moment, please tell us your thoughts by writing a reader's review. Thank you.

The Gift reader reviews

from New Zealand


I really enjoyed the whole series, had me up reading late into the night!

from United Kingdom


The magical background (and it appears a large part of the plot) is a rip-off of Ursula le Guins the earth-sea series. The path of character development of the heroine is about as cliched a "coming of age/rites of passage" as you can get. The redeeming feature is the poetic quality of the writing. So, nothing special, nothing original, but not too badly written.

from Kenya


The book was really good and I loved the descriptions. I too found it very very similar to the Inheritance Cycle by Christoper Paolini. I don't understand how the reviewer finds two very similar books so different. I find it very pretentious on his part!

from Cumbria


I love the Inheritance cycle, and think that it is quite similar to the books of Pellinor.

from England


I found it one of the most interesting books I've ever read. Croggon has done an amazing job of creating a whole other world-the description is perfectly detailed and created clear images in my head whilst I read it. Cannot wait to read the other three!

from India


It's a thrilling read and the fact that it has so much description in itself made it special. Describing a world that was fabricated, even if she was the one who made it, is not that easy. I loved it!

from Scotland


The books are great. "too detailed" you say? That's a load of rubbish. The detail allows you to envision the world and so appreciate its beauty and loss. Too many people nowadays just want: "He killed a hundred orcs whilst blindfolded, then went to sleep. The next day he killed 500 orcs for breakfast".

from China


I actually really didn't like it. It was too detailed in places and she was just always going somewhere but hardly ever getting there. And it did remind me of The Lord of the Rings... but not in a good way.

from England


The first review pretty much summed it up! Sometimes a little too much detail in places where it isn't really necessary..... Loved all 4 books and I started and finished them in 2 weeks, so now im going to read them all again at a slower pace...

7.8/10 from 10 reviews

Write a reader review

Thank you for taking the time to write a review on this book, it really makes a difference and helps readers to find their perfect book.

First name

Country where you live


Your rating (out of 10)

Your review

More recommended reading in this genre

Looking for more suggestions? Try these pages:

Read a free preview of The Gift by Alison Croggon