The Hobbit by JRR Tolkien
J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit is one of the best known and best loved fantasy books. First published by George Allen & Unwin in 1937, The Hobbit has been translated into over 50 different languages and sold well over 100 million copies.
The Hobbit was written by Professor Tolkien for the reading pleasure of his own children, of whom Christopher became the editor of Tolkien's posthumous work such as The Silmarillion and The Book of Lost Tales.
This is a far more light-hearted tale than the Lord of the Rings and introduces to the world the unforgettable Bilbo, Gandalf and Gollum. The Hobbit is a book that can be enjoyed by children and adults alike and authors from J.K. Rowling to David Gemmell class it as an inspiration upon their own work.
A book full of adventure, heroism, song and laughter, featuring landscapes that are quintessentially English - the Shire the Hobbits inhabit could easily be an England of yesteryear. But soon the Shire is left behind and Bilbo, our reluctant hero, encounters Dwarves, Elves, Goblins, Eagles and Wizards as the party passes through Rivendell, The Misty Mountains and Mirkwood on their way to the Lonely Mountain, in order to take back treasure stolen by the great dragon Smaug.
One of the most appealing aspects of The Hobbit is that we can all find our inner-Hobbit; the part of us that wants nothing by an easy and confortable life. But there is still something inside all of us that perks up at the thought of adventure and a journey into the unknown and I think this is why The Hobbit is such a firm favourite and fondly remembered by all who read it.
The mother of our particular hobbit - what is a hobbit? I suppose hobbits need some description nowadays, since they have become rare and shy of the Big People, as they call us. They are (or were) a little people, about half our height, and smaller than the bearded dwarves. Hobbits have no beards. There is little or no magic about them, except the ordinary everyday sort which helps them to disappear quietly and quickly when large stupid folk like you and me come blundering along, making a noise like elephants which they can hear a mile off. They are inclined to be fat in the stomach; they dress in bright colour's (chiefly green and yellow); wear no shoes, because their feet grow natural leather soles and thick brown hair like the stuff on their heads (which is curly); have long clever brown fingers, good-natured faces, and laugh deep fruity laughs (especially after dinner which they have twice a day when they can get it).
From: The Hobbit - Chapter: An Unexpected Party
I would suggest reading the illustrated version if you have the choice, the artwork by Alan Lee* is so good that it manages to improve a story that is already fabulous.
The Hobbit is quite simply a must read, a real delight.
* Alan Lee is an English artist, he has studied Celtic and Norse myths and remains fascinated by mythology. He was inspired by The Lord of the Rings and as well as providing the artwork for the Hobbit he also illustrated the centenary edition of The Lord of the Rings.
This The Hobbit book review was written by Floresiensis
Have you read The Hobbit?
We've found that while readers like to know what we think of a book they find additional reader reviews a massive help in deciding if it is the right book for them. So if you have a spare moment, please tell us your thoughts by writing a reader's review. Thank you.
The Hobbit reader reviews
Shankar from India
It is an amazing book. The language is pretty good and the storyline is amazing though it can be slow-paced at times.
Carol from California
It's a wonderful read. The pages literally turn themselves! A must-read book.
Me from Somewhere
It was a very interesting book. Very slow at first but once you got into the book it was was hard to put down. It was a “Tolkien” of excellence... sorry bad pun.
Josh from Canada
The hobbit is such a boring book. Has a easy to understand timeline and doesn't get you thinking.
Kristian from Denmark
A great introduction to the Lord of the Rings universe. It's well written and super exciting.
Charlotte from United Kingdom
I love this book, it has so much excitement and imagination and it was hard to put the book down!
Anonymous from California, UNITED STATES
I could give it a 0. It was very boring and not interesting at all. Don't recommend. They made me read this book while in 7th grade. I was excited at first because it was our first time getting one of these books. Made us do toooooooo many work and worksheets. I failed most of the quizzes taken on the book. I HATE IT.
Nathan from Australia
Amazing book. Never forgot the storyline because I read it too much!!
Anson from Hong Kong
This book was totally AWESOME. It’s plot is pretty nice and the story flows. How could people not like this? Bilbo Baggins was an amazing character and he ROCKS!!! A few months ago, I had a hard time finding a classical book to read, so I asked my parents and my friends what I should read. A few of them told me to read Harry Potter, but I got tired of those books. Others told me to check out the Hunger Games series, but I thought it was meaningless. The remaining few told me to take a look at Tolkien’s work, so I checked out The Hobbit. I spent 2 hours reading it and it was awesome. Best book ever.
Jasmine from USA
LOVED the book. My classmates had a hard time understanding and so did I.
Allen from Philippines
I watched the movie of this and I think the book was okay, but it was so simple and straight forwards! There were no deeper meanings and it didn't make you think, excluding the part of the riddles. But I would expect this book to have made a bunch of metaphors and stuff like in the movie. I like LOTR better than this so far. After Bilbo left Gollum, it got really really boring. (But I'm imagining the movie part while I reading the book because it's awesome while imagining it).
Izzy from England
AMAZING BOOK LOVE IT SO MUCH BETTER THEN THE FILMS!!!!!!
Evelyn from USA
I liked this book ok, but it was really hard to read, and almost impossible to fully understand what was going on without having to re-reading the chapter.
Max from Aus
I am 11yo and have already read this book 7 times. I have also read the whole of the Lord of the Rings twice and the Silmarillion once and loved them all. The Hobbit is my favorite book in the whole world.
Sofia from America
I loved the movies and I like the whole storyline of the book but for me, it was really hard to read and understand what I was reading. The style of writing was very confusing and I felt like there were some grammatical issues (no commas where a comma should’ve been). Overall I was disappointed when I read this. My expectations were too high.
El from Australia
Great, went bit slow sometimes but when it got into the exciting books I couldn't stop reading!!
Emily from USA
If I could rate it an eleven out of ten, I would. A beautifully written book. It makes me want to live there!
Juliet from England
I am a twelve year old reading the book for homework given to me by school. I am currentley on the fourth chapter of the book and I can't stop reading it! Each chapter is beautifully written and the storyline is amazing! This is a book that when you get to the end you will remember all the characters and the story and it will leave you wanting more! I highley recommend this book to anyone willing for an exciting adventure with some of Tolkien's best work!
Jonah from South Africa
It was an awesome book to read. I watched the movie first and I prefer the book over the movie! It's also full of adventure and one of the best books I've read.
Someone from The Netherlands
I'm a fourteen year old learning English as a second language. I had to pick and read a book for my English class. Our teacher said that we had to pick something not too hard, like The Hobbit or Lord of the Rings. As you might guess I didn't really listen to her and decided to prove her wrong with reading The Hobbit. I really enjoyed the story and the use of words didn't really bother me at all. This book totally deserves a 10 out of 10. (Sorry for bad grammar)
Trenton from America
Really inspiring book.
Anon from UK
This book was truly amazing. The first chapter was a little hard to understand, but once I got going I was hooked. The classic writing style was kind of hard to comprehend for me at some points. But overall, great story, great characters, and great details. *Please note that I am only in the fifth grade
Angel from Australia
It's a really good book with so much detail and mystery! We have to read it for a school assignment and all of my friends say it is dull and confusing. Personally i don't agree. Love it!
Anisio from long Island
THE BOOK IS WAY BETTER THAN ANY OTHER!!!
Taylor from Australia
It is a great book.
Alex from America
You can tell that a linguistic professor wrote it.
Amber from Australia
I believe that this is a very well written and inspiring novel. I am in 8th grade and are reading it as the class novel. While it can be a slow read at times it is overall a brilliant read. just as a side note, I don't understand why people giving this a 1/10 are even here, like if you hate the book so much and are to dumb to even slightly understand the quite simple storyline, then why waste more time leaving a review??? just saying XD
Jeff from England
A brilliant book.
Steve from America
I'm by no means a literary critic or an avid reader, but it is quite a good book, very mystical and exciting, though it can be boring at times, although this is the case with any book. If you're looking for a good classic then this would be a good book to pick up.
Seth from Canada
MnM from UK
This book is amazing!!!!!! Love it!!!!!! :)
Paul from Australia
Lol the only people that didn't like the book were because they were in year 7 or something. I'm still pretty young, and I'll admit the vocabulary, etc. is a bit old-fashioned and hard to understand, but otherwise 10/10. The movies are great too.
J from America
this book is SO bad. I was forced to read it for school. It is extremely boring and no joke, everytime I mustered myself to finally read a chapter, I fell asleep whilst reading it. The storyline is confusing and lifeless. The style it is written in would be fine, if this book was a poem from the Middle Ages. Very confusing and very slow. I am on chapter 15 and I still don't know what the whole summary of this story is. I don't understand what Bilbo is looking for, why he steals from Smaug or whatever the dragons name is, and what I mostly don't understand is how in the H*ll this book could be enjoyed by anyone. It's substantially overrated in my opinion. I would give it 0 stars If I could. And just to add on, I am a very good reader, and I usuallycomprehend books very well but this one is so bad, and it's not only the style of the book that drove me away but the un-interesting content. I could rant about how much I hate this book for days, lol.
Car from Hong Kong
Those who rated 1 is total **** who knows nothing of literature.
Rob from Round the roundabout
Great book and all but a little confusing at times as well.
Jack from Spain
I think the book is really boring. It is really hard to understand for me (I am 16 and I am from Spain). I think it is overrated and my expectations were better. The story was realy fake and the fantasy sucks.
Ashley from North America
This book is a great introduction (and standalone) for anyone interested in reading the Lord of the Rings! I've seen a lot of complaints about the book being too "complicated," but I had this book read aloud to me at 8 years of age and I understood it just fine. This book is narrated beautifully with dark and light themes of heroism and with characters that you don't easily forget. Tolkien is a magnificent writer and this is a book that you don't want to pass up.
TH from US
It is a good book.
Edgardo from California
I'm in 7th grade and they made me read this book. At first I was excited because I loved the movie but when I started I hated it. It was boring and to complicated to read.
Jackson from United States
A Fantastic Journey Through Middle Earth. Are you craving an extremely immersive book that you just can’t stop reading? The Hobbit is one of the few books that has ever done this to me, being the beginning of a series of books that is probably my favorite of all time. The Hobbit is a fictional fantasy book appropriate for 10+ ages. The Hobbit follows the story of Bilbo Baggins, a hobbit, who is on a journey to steal back the magnificent treasures of the dragon Smaug. The book managed to cover many things that I wanted to see whilst reading. I was immersed in the world, the characters, and the storyline. The plot never failed me. I always felt like I was in a productive part of the book, rather than a slow, unimaginative, and boring section. It is fun to read, and the series of books that it continues into, the Lord of the Rings, is an addition to it all, and provides nothing but more content to explore. The Hobbit has the power to draw in any reader, and keep them for the entire ride. It has an amazing story, colorful characters, and an unforgettable adventure. The only problem was that it didn’t last very long, I just couldn’t stop reading!
allaboutBooks from United States
Loved this book! Have been a fan of Lord of the Rings and Tolkien since I was four years old. The author never lets down. It's an intriguing story as well as fun read; a great prelude to a great trilogy. If you liked this book like I did, you'll probably like the book Some Must Fall. There's a cool website at: thecomingcrown.com
Jet from United States
This is an amazing book full of adventure and even thrilling at times, I have read it multiple times and always have enjoyed it. If you like a book about adventure then i highly recommend this one.
Tanya from India
Its an amazing book. I think everyone should read it.
Alex from Williams
One of my first books that I read (and some of you can relate yes?). The story is fairly linear, and no real character progression. Black and white stuff here. But saying that, it still has that great fantasy feel. Strongly believe its best to read this at a younger age and might seem to simple for an adult reader.
Micah from Illinois
#greatest book ever# blessed
Bilbo Baggins from The Shire
Very good. But harder to read then your average Harry Potter book.
Tommy from W.V.
I love it!!!
Barin from India
It is the one of the best books I ever read. It is quite a simple language and is easy to read.
Agrima from Nepal
Liked it very much. Great work J R R Tolkien.
Liam from Canada
It was very hard to read. I didn't like it much.
Mat from Canada
It's the worst book I have ever read.
Luna from Denmark
Bilbo Baggins became my - and I am sure many other readers - favourite fantasy character of all time. The Hobbit has everything a fantasy lover could want: hobbits, dwarves, trolls, goblins, wargs, giant eagles, wizards, shape-shifters, elves, giant-spiders and of course, a dragon. Add to this a mythology that feels authentic and a love that shines out in all the locations and characters and you have a masterpiece of children's literature, Read it to your kids. Read it your yourself.
P****t from Canada
In class we're reading this, and nobody thought it would be good, because the majority of the class only ever read either books about romance (the girls), comics or celebrity magazines. Whenever we read short stories in English class, we would be sooo bored, but this book was actually good (well so far it's good; we haven't finished it yet). It also helped, that we didn't read it all in a couple of days, we spent time with each chapter, really taking the time to understand it, and that helped the class to fall in love with the book. I never thought I would be searching up this book and now actually writing a review for it, especially since I was one of the people who wanted to read The Hobbit the least, but here I am. I really like this book. I'm a teen in grade 9 right now, and this book really isn't bad, you just have to take time to really understand it and eventually (or hopefully) you'll start liking it too!
BANTERMAN from Over the hill and round the bend
I read this book a few years ago and loved it. I own the Xbox game and the box set of movies. By the end of the book you really start to "feel" for all the main characters. I also love the LOTR trilogy.
Dhisana from India
Hobbit!!!!! It's so great!! Even if it's a classic it's very interesting to read! And Bilbo will always remain close to my heart! Great work JRR Tolkien.!!
Paul from Canada
I am in love with the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings movies. I've watched every single one so far. I am grade 6 right now and I just started reading The Hobbit. So far I am in Chapter 2, but it is really hard to read. I don't know, the movie was excellent but the book I think is too hard for a grade 6. Movie rating is 10/10 but the book is 5/10 because of hard reading times.
Fili and Kili of the dead from Dwarf Heaven
I found it amazing. I read it while in my last year of primary school and found it amazing. It was interesting to say the least. But all in all, I loved it in every way. I can't wait until I read the Lord Of The Rings series.
Daniel from Australia
This is a brilliant book. I first read it when I was 11 and I love it. I am doing it for a project right now because of how good it is. A brilliant modern classic recommended to all.
Me from Here
This is a really good book, the language too is pretty good. I did this for my drama exam and there are a lot of good excerpts and there is good scope for improvement... if you can imitate Gollum's voice its even better. :)
Ian Phares from US
THE BEST BOOK EVER!!!
Tracy from England
I love this book immensely!!!
Kaylee from New Zealand
The book is amazing! It's such an interesting read and seeing what Peter Jackson has done with the book is interesting. I would totally suggest this book to other readers if they haven't read it already.
Adele from United States
I think the book was okay, but it was so simple and straight forwards! There were no deeper meanings and it didn't make you think, excluding the part of the riddles. I love Tolkien, but I would expect him to have made a bunch of metaphors and stuff like that! He is a great author, but this is too simple for me to like.
Petwa from Murica
Well Julia you should go back to reading Twilight!
Himika from India
A fitting prequel to Tolkien's epic!! I liked LOTR better but The Hobbit is also a wonderful book!! Bilbo is simply adorable! The only thing I did not like was the lack of females (which is why I am giving it a 9), but that does not reduce the book's charm. While LOTR is a more dark novel, The Hobbit captures every young readers' imagination. I read the book when I was thirteen, and two years later my heart still lingers in the green fields of the Shire, the dark forest of Mirkwood and the steep slopes of the lonely mountain. A definite masterpiece!
Bilbo from The Shire
I love this book, it is literally my life and Frodo's in a little trilogy.
Jasmine from Slovenia
The only reason that I have given it a one, is because there are no zeros or N/A options and I have not actually read the book yet. I plan to check it out of the library tomorrow, because I feel as if I owe it to a good friend of mine to read at least one of his favorite books, because he's read two of my favorites already. Truthfully, I haven't had a lot of exposure to the fantasy genre, being more of a realistic fiction person, but I suppose that there's a first time for everything:) Thanks for letting on-the-fence readers such as myself your opinions. It always helps:):):):)
Christine from The United States
The Hobbit is one of my favorite books. It's a great story, full of adventure and laughter and sadness. My favorite part is when they go to Mirkwood. I've always been fascinated by elves, especially Legolas and was happy when I got to read about where he was from and meet his father. I absolutely adore this book and really enjoy the movies as well!
Rakshit from India
I felt bad when this story ended, I was lost in story. And Bilbo, my friend, I felt like I was with him throughout the story, doing adventures... Love this book.
Aasim from India
Awesome book. Love it.
Aniya from US
This was an amzing fairytale. It left me wanting more and feeling like Fili, Kili and Throin at the battle of the five armies. Tolkien to me is an amazing author that created a fantasy land where it doesn't end with happily ever after. He shows that fantasy isn't necessarily a happy thing. He showed me this. Thank you J.R.R. Tolkien.
Ridz from India
Oh gosh!!!!!!!! Love dis book ;) Dis can't be compared to Harry Potter or Percy Jackson n stuff coz this falls in a different league..... the descriptions r so vivid I really think I am ready to meet d Hobbit n party n go for an adventure. Book is better dan d movie.
Navid from Bangladesh
The book was just spectacular . The story was amazing, awesome, astounding, fantastic and mindblowing.
Jen from US
The Hobbit is a children's book that fully deserves the tag classic. I have read it twice now and each time have found myself completely lost in the world that Tolkien has created. The book is definitely better than the film.
Max from USA
Although this book is slightly hard to read, once you get into the story it is interesting and exciting. J.R.R. Tolkien conveys a great message that there is more to a person than meets the eye. Through all of the adversity that Bilbo has to endure, he uses his wits to be the unlikely hero in every situation. Although he is not the ideal hero, Gandalf sees that Bilbo is a courageous person inside. This book is appealing to all ages and to both men and women. Just as there is more to Bilbo Baggins than meets the eye, this book is much deeper than just an adventure story.
Everybody from Everywhere
This book is the Jesus of fantasy novels!
RJ from Philippines
BEST BOOK EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Henry from Not telling
I LOVE THIS PIECE OF LEGEND BY DR.LEGEND HIMSELF J.R.R.TOLKIEN
Levi from America
It's a great book that deserves more than just my mere praise. I applaud Tolkien not only for his brilliant series, but his vast imagination and contribution to the world of writing.
Pelle from Sweden
Fantastic! I have read The Hobbit several times, and it is one of my favorite books of all time.
Nick from Canada
Ignacio from United States
This is the best book ever, the description was so vivid, it was like I was in the book, and the adventure thrilled me with every word.
Classified from Australia
Awesome book, I think everyone should get it. I can't wait until the move comes out, so exited!
Julia from USA
Worst book ever written. I hated it.
Kevan from India
I am surprised that The Hobbit is as low as the 18th in your list. It is an outstanding novel with few peers.
Darin from USA
Amazing book, I love how it describes everything, it feels like I could envision being there. A must read.
Nobody from Nowhere
I love this book, it's full of adventure danger, and self conflict.
Joshua from England
I gave the hobbit a 10 because it is dynamic and so well written and so detailed that I could never possibly vote it lower then a 10, never. For those of you who have read the brilliant The Lord of the Rings would realise the structure of the book and how diffrently it is written. So to the point, The Hobbit is a classic and Tolkien is the king of all fantasy and as a 13 year old school-nerd would like to become an author so in a word I will describe The Hobbit as brilliant. Thanks for reading.
Luffy from One Piece
It was a really epic book but some of the words were kind of hard...
Tom from UK
Great for ages 14+ if you love fantasy. Not as complicated as The Lord of the Rings, so it's a great taster for the fantasy genre and Tolkien's books meaning a younger audience will enjoy it just as much as the older audience.
Henry Pickup from Leeds
I think the book is gripping because when I read the first page I went on and read a 100 pages in one night and then the next day I finished it!
A.R. Fallaha from Syria
This is the best book I've ever read.
Jonathon from Glasgow
A great read, just finished reading it for the first time and I'm sure I'll read it many more times. It chronicles the quests of the hobbit Bilbo Baggins on his journey to the Lonely Mountain and his adventures when he finally arrives. It is a deceptively large adventure in a deceptively small book.
Mariah from Arizona
I really enjoyed reading The Hobbit. I like fantasy in general, and I like seeing the backstory to Lord of the Rings, which I am currently reading. Both are good stories, but The Hobbit is faster-moving, more lighthearted, and somewhat easier to get through.
Je from Banbry
I love The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings is just as good. I love them both!
JOJO from Miami
The Hobbit will have any reader lying on the couch for hours not wanting it to end.
SIMPLE SPLENDID IMAGINATION AND BRILLIANT ADVENTURE Simple - splendid imagination and brilliant adventure.
Mimi from Manila
Would love to read it over and over. Tolkien could bring the stuff in children's dreams and nightmares to life.
Peter from Canada
The Hobbit is a recital of events, expressing divinity abroad an air of nothingness, an otherwise logical mind will find it will be able to start an unquenchable, superabounding desire to know more about Tolkien and his works of secondary identity.
Anthony from Cardiff
This book is brilliant and a must read! I preferred it to the Lord of the Rings.
Rob from Huddersfield
Thank you to my year 1 high school english teacher (sorry, I forget your name). This was the first book he assigned me to read, and I have loved it ever since. What else is there to say but perfection and when my son is old enough to appreciate it, I will read it to him too.
Aaron from USA
This book was recommended to me by my freshman English teacher in high school. It is one of my, if not my favorite book of all times. I will keep reading this book until the day I die, and I will also have it berried with me. :)
Nicolau from USA
This is the best book I've ever read and I believe it is his best work, much better than LOTR.
Likkamatti from Finland
It was so much fun reading The Hobbit. It wasn`t better than LOTR but it`s still one of my favourite fantasy books. It was happier than LOTR and it`s more comfortable for younger readers. A very good book.
My favorite fantasy book. Tolkien is simply amazing when it comes to writing. Bilbo is such a good and solid character!
Unknown from Coolsville
I love all the Tolkien books but this one is my favourite!
Lara from Stoke
This book is now over 70 years old and reads as well today as it did back then. The label "Timeless classic" is given to too many books but in the case of The Hobbit it is fully deserved. Bilbo Baggins is the best character ever and even without the Lord of the Rings this book would still be around today. What can I say? A timeless classic!
Jane from England
The Hobbit is a lovely book, I must have read it at least 15 times between the ages of 12 and 30 and it gets better each time. I think you have the rating spot on with 9 out of 10.
9/10 from 109 reviews
Write a reader review
Thank you for taking the time to write a review on this book, it really makes a difference and helps readers to find their perfect book.
More recommended reading in this genre
The Dragonsdome Chronicles
Quenelda has always had a magical bond with dragons, and her greatest wish is to fly one and fight alongside her father in the war against the hobgoblins. Root, on the othe...
The Dragons of Ordinary Farm
Tyler and Lucinda have to spend summer with their Uncle Gideon, a farmer. They soon discover that Ordinary Farm is well, no ordinary farm. The bellowing in the barn comes n...
Drewdop, long-suffering Royal Astrologer and Court Illusionist to King Credos of the Central Realms, teams up with lonely, universally shunned, half-ogre, Urquhart, to defe...
Looking for more suggestions? Try these pages:
Best of 2016
The Story of Tomkin and the Dragon
Tomkin Thornhewn, youngest son of the Duke of Marshwell, has a problem: he’s not heroic. Regardless of his aspirations, the bookish, untrained young man is better suited...
Books of the Month
A selection of books - old and new alike - that were a joy to read.
Forget the old days. Forget summer. Forget warmth. Forget anything that doesn’t help you survive in the endless white wilderness beyond the edges of a fallen world. Lynn McBride has learned much since society collapsed in the face of nuclear war and the relentless spread of disease. As the memories of her old life continue to haunt, she...
Paris was supposed to save Hallie. Now... well, let’s just say Paris has other ideas. There’s a strange woman called The Chronometrist who will not leave her al...
A corrupted city. A dark dream of power. Luke is a prisoner, condemned for a murder he didn’t commit. Abi is a fugitive, desperate to free him before magic breaks his...
The Fifth Empire of Man
Rob J Hayes
The Pirate Isles are united under Drake Morrass’ flag, but the war has only just begun. There’s still a long way to go before he’s able to call himself Ki...
Ian C Esslemont
After the disappointments of Li Heng, Dancer and Kellanved wash up on a small insignificant island named Malaz. Immediately, of course, Kellanved plans to take it over. To ...
Age of Swords
Michael J Sullivan
Raithe, the God Killer, may have started the rebellion by killing a Fhrey, but long-standing enmities dividing the Rhunes make it all but impossible to unite against the co...
A Time of Dread
The Ben-Elim, a race of warrior angels, once vanquished a mighty demon horde. Now they rule the Banished lands. But their dominion is brutally enforced and their ancient en...