The Subtle Knife by Philip Pullman

Rate and review The Subtle Knife! | What does everyone else think?

Summary I enjoyed this book immensely, more so than the first, which I think is how it should be.

The sequel to Northern Lights, this is the second book in the 'His Dark Materials' Trilogy and introduces the character of Will Parry, a young boy who lives in Oxford (our world) with his ailing and increasingly confused mother and now on the run from a number of 'men in black' who seem to be searching for some letters sent from his missing explorer father, whom Will and his mother has not seen or heard from for years. After a scuffle with these mystery men, when they break into Will's home, one of the agents is accidentally killed and now Will must run for his life and try to find his father in order to help him and his mother. With his mother placed in the care of his old piano teacher Will ventures off and soon stumbles across a window to another world. Cittigazze is the City he stumbles across; but all is not well here, the place is deserted apart from a small, wild band of children who talk of spectres chasing away the adults. It is here he meets Lyra Belacqua, our heroine from the first book, who has traveled through the window from her world through the Northern Lights. Lyra has her Althiometer stolen and must retrieve something call the Subtle Knife in order to get it back. It soon becomes clear her and Will's meeting is not merely coincidence as Will becomes the successor to the previous owner of the Subtle Knife, which was made and resides in the City of Citigazze and is the key to opening an infinite number of windows to an infinite number of other worlds.

Now they must find Will's father in order to put things right in Will's world and help his mother, but Mrs Coulter, who Lyra has already learnt is her real but not naturally maternal mother, has other plans for Lyra and is determined to destroy her. With the help of the witches and now also angels, Will and Lyra set off on this new and very dangerous quest.

I enjoyed this book immensely, more so than the first, which I think is how it should be with a sequel. The character of Lyra continues to develop, with the logical and mature Will at her side, whom Lyra admires and looks up to but would never admit. Lyra at first is almost repulsed by this new character as he comes from a world where you can not see a persons daemon, unlike her own dear Pan. But Pullman assures the reader that although we might not be able to see our daemon in this world, we do indeed have one, which is a lovely bit of fantasy for children (and Adults) to wonder what their own daemon might be. Mrs Coulter continues as the cold hearted anti-heroine who you just love to hate and her own daemon is as spiteful and cruel as ever. The other, by now much loved, characters such as Iorek Byrnison and Lee Scorsby are here, woven into the plots lines as the two main characters of Will and Lyra jump from world to world, giving comfortable and familiar territory in a very fast paced and ever changing story. Again, there are real instances of grief in this book and it is by no means all happy ever after, but this makes the story all the richer and more absorbing for it.

The Subtle Knife (His Dark Materials): His Dark Materials 2 (Amazon.co.uk)

Author: Philip Pullman
Binding: Paperback
Number of pages: 368
Publication date: 2007-03-05
Publisher: Scholastic

RRP: £7.99
Lowest new price: £1.53
Lowest used price: £0.01

At the end of The Northern Lights, Lyra Silvertongue watched in fear and fascination as her father, Lord Asriel, created a bridge between worlds. Lyra and her daemon, Pantalaimon, are now lost in an alternate universe where they meet Will Parry, a fugitive from a third universe. Will has found a small window between Cittagazze (a place where children roam unchecked but invisible Specters suck the spirit out of adults) and his Oxford, which, with its Burger Kings and cars, is frighteningly different from the Oxford Lyra knows.

Will's father, an explorer, disappeared years ago, but recently some odd characters have started asking questions about him, and now, having accidentally killed one of them, Will is wanted by the police. Armed with the Subtle Knife, a tool that cuts any material (including that which separates universes) and Lyra's alethiometer, the children set out to find John Parry, with adults of various stripes in desperate pursuit.

Lyra's finest qualities, her courage and quick mind, are stretched to the limit as she has to lie, cheat and steal to keep herself and Will out of danger. However, she must also learn when to tell the truth and when to trust, for, though she does not yet know it, she has a huge part to play in the upcoming battle between Good and Evil.
Amazon.co.uk Review

Subtle Knife. (Amazon.com)

Author: Philip Pullman
Binding: Paperback
Number of pages: 368
Publication date: 2007-01-01
Publisher: Scholastic.

RRP:
Lowest new price:
Lowest used price: $0.54

Susanna from Isle of Man
"Northern Lights was good, this is even better! We have all our favourite characters from the first book and are introduced to new one's as we go along, one of whom is Will. This is a wonderful, fast-paced story that follows on nicely from Northern Lights and sets the scene perfectly for The Amber Spyglass. It's best to read Northern Lights first or else you may find certain things not making sense and this may take away from the enjoyment you get from it."

Submit your own mini-review

Let people know what you think about The Subtle Knife. You can write your own mini-review and give the book the rating that you think it deserves. Your reviews will go towards giving The Subtle Knife its overall rating that will decide where The Subtle Knife finishes in the top 100 fantasy books of all time.

Books you may also enjoy...

The Spook’s Apprentice by Joseph Delaney

Thomas Ward is the seventh son of a seventh son and has been apprenticed to the local Spook. The job is hard, the spook is distant and many apprentices have failed before him. Somehow Thomas must learn how to exorcise ghosts, contain witches and bind boggarts. But when he is tricked into freeing Mother Malkin, the most evil witch in the Country, the horror begins… ... read the full review

Summary: Chilling, memorable and full of wonderful characters.

Reader reviews | Write review

The Death Defying Pepper Roux by Geraldine McCaughrean

When Pepper Roux was born his aunt foretold that he would not live past 14 years of age. Throughout his childhood his parents haven't bothered with him much, knowing that his life would be short-lived. So when Pepper wakes up on his 14th birthday he knows this will be the day that he'll die. But as the day wears on, and Pepper finds himself still alive, he decides to set off to sea in an attempt to try and avoid death for as long as possible. As time goes on Pepper steps into many roles and personas and has numerous outrageous adventures. But can he stay one step ahead of death? Or will fate catch up with him? And, if he does live, which of his many lives will he choose to adopt? This riot of a story is a wonderful adventure, and Pepper is an unforgettable character who stays with you long after his story has been told. ... read the full review

Summary: A delightful and whimsical book that highlights the power and wonder of imagination.

Reader reviews | Write review

Ella Enchanted by Gail Carson Levine

Ella is given a blessing at birth by a very stupid fairy: She gets the gift of obedience! but the blessing turns into a horror for Ella who literally has to do what anyone and everyone tells her, from sweeping the floor to giving up a precious necklace! She has to battle with ogres and wicked stepsisters, make friends and loose them, and even deny she loves her Prince Char to save his life and his kingdom. The story overthrows the stereotypes of the original Cinderella when Ella breaks the curse -- not the prince -- saving not only herself, but Prince Char as well. And Ella rejects his proposal of marriage, at least until she decides herself to propose to him! And the curse is only broken because she's said 'No!' rather than 'Yes!'. ... read the full review

Summary: Ella Enchanted is an enchanting re-telling of the Cinderella fairy tale.

Reader reviews | Write review

Also in this sub-genre...

• The Spook’s Apprentice by Joseph Delaney
• The Death Defying Pepper Roux by Geraldine McCaughrean
• Ella Enchanted by Gail Carson Levine
• Who is Charlie Keeper? by Marcus Alexander
• The Amber Spyglass by Philip Pullman
• Abhorsen by Garth Nix
• The Spook’s Mistake by Joseph Delaney
• Northern Lights by Philip Pullman
• The Prophecy Keepers by Melaine Bryant
• The Spook’s Curse by Joseph Delaney
• The Spook’s Secret by Joseph Delaney
• The Spook’s Battle by Joseph Delaney
• The Spook’s Stories: Witches by Joseph Delaney
• Lirael by Garth Nix
• Once Upon A Time In The North by Philip Pullman
• The Magician’s Apprentice by Trudi Canavan
• Mister Monday by Garth Nix
• Grim Tuesday by Garth Nix
• The Spook’s Tale by Joseph Delaney
• Dragon Horse by Peter Ward
• The Spook’s Sacrifice by Joseph Delaney
• Sabriel by Garth Nix