The Bookseller's Tale by Ann Swinfen

(7.0/10) I would encourage anyone who loves the Bartholomew mysteries to read these

It is inevitable that Ann Swinfen's latest theme – a foray into fourteenth century Oxford murder mysteries – will be compared to the peerless Susanna Gregory. The parallels are clear: University versus townsfolk and a mild-mannered, reluctant sleuth with his wealthier, altruistic sidekick. There is plenty of reference to matters ecclesiastic, a mystery that is intellectual, characters who are well-rounded, gently pleasing, and a narrative that moves from place to place in a tidy fashion. All liberally peppered with references to a city that shows off the author's personal knowledge of the a post-plague Oxford.
 
It is a winning formula, as Ms Gregory has demonstrated with her 20+ novels of Matthew Bartholomew and Cambridge.
 
The opening novel of this new venture by Swinfen introduces us to bookseller, Nicholas Elyot. A widower, with his young daughter, Alysoun, he lives with his sister, Margaret, plying a trade as a scrivener, a bookseller. He has two employees, Walter and Roger: a small but tidy business that guarantees him sufficient income for the author to use pecuniary methods to elicit information and action during the novel.
 
The story opens with Elyot's daughter, as all 5 year olds are wont, begging him to save a canine litter from being drowned by one Oxford's millers. The result is this family expand by one puppy, Rowan. Giving in to his daughter's pleas to see the rest housed, leads Nicholas to stumble across the body of a University student, William Farringdon, floating in the river Cherwell. His discovery of a stab mark in the back of this talented young scrivener pricks at the conscience of our sleuth. This, coupled with the familiar apathy of the authorities to investigate and the tensions over jurisdiction between university colleges and the town, encourages him to investigate further with the reluctant assistance of his friend, Jordain.
 
Quickly he establishes some kind of motive, associated with an Irish Psalter, and two mendacious, shifty villains. There is a subtle plot of greed afoot at Merton College.
 
Not wishing to give away spoilers, this reviewer cannot mention any further character names. This is where Swinfen needs to improve. There is a dearth of characters which means it is fairly simple for a reader to work out motive, murderers by the time the book is half done. The denouement is also weak: it is the last action and should be more climatic than it is. Given the evil-doers are built up as rough, murderous characters then the capture is all too tame, meek and mild. Not wholly convincing. Yet, for all this, one keeps reading because Swinfen possesses the undoubted talent to write a captivating story. The novels just need more depth: characters, action, events, intellectual enigmaticism.

So, is Ms Swinfen as good as Ms Gregory?

Honestly, no (she could reach that lofty height). But, she is clearly excellent at the genre and I would encourage anyone who loves the Bartholomew mysteries to read these (three novels at the time of this review). I don't think you'll be disappointed.

Review by

15+

The Bookseller's Tale reader reviews

from UK

I must agree with the review above, as far as the less than compelling plot. But for anyone who likes the medieval period, and enjoys cozy English mysteries, this is a perfect fit. I took real pleasure in the active decency of the (good) characters--indeed, the bad guys are generally weaker and less interesting than the good. I look forward to the continuation of the series, which I hope will grow in depth and complexity of characterization.

8.5/10 from 2 reviews

Write a reader review

Your rating out of 10

All reviews for Ann Swinfen's Oxford Medieval Mysteries series

The Bookseller's Tale

Oxford Medieval Mysteries #1 written by Ann Swinfen

Oxford, Spring 1353. When young bookseller Nicholas Elyot discovers the body of student William Farringdon floating in the river Cherwell, it looks like a drowning. Soon, h [...]

Published: 2017

Our rating: 7.0 | positive reader reviews

15+

Books you may also enjoy

Death in St James's Park

by Susanna Gregory

Five years after Charles II's triumphant return to London there is growing mistrust of his extravagant court and of corruption among his officials - and when a cart lad [...]

Series: The Exploits of Thomas Chaloner: Book 8
Published: 2013

Score: 100

Our rating: 10.0 | 0 positive reader reviews

15+

The Seven Lies

by Daniel Springfield

Following the success of his previous book The Six Secrets, Daniel Springfield has once again brought into question the facts surrounding seven tragic events over the past [...]

Series: NA
Published: 2020

Score: 0

Our rating: 10.0 | 0 positive reader reviews

15+

Mystery in the Minster

by Susanna Gregory

In 1358 the fledging college of Michaelhouse in Cambridge is in need of extra funds. A legacy from the Archbishop of York of a parish close to that city promises a welcome [...]

Series: The Chronicles of Matthew Bartholomew #17
Published: 2011

Score: 95

Our rating: 9.5 | 0 positive reader reviews

15+

The Luminaries

by Eleanor Catton

It is 1866, and Walter Moody has come to make his fortune upon the New Zealand goldfields. On arrival, he stumbles across a tense gathering of twelve local men, who have me [...]

Series: NA
Published: 2013

Score: 95

Our rating: 9.5 | 0 positive reader reviews

15+