A Just Determination by John G Hemry (JAG In Space: Book 1)

9/10 An absorbing and intelligent science fiction drama.

Ensign Paul Sinclair is assigned to the orbiting space warship the USS Michaelson as the ship’s lone legal officer. When the ship’s captain is accused of ordering the destruction of a civilian research vessel, and commanded to return to port for court-martial, Sinclair must testify at the hearing.

With his own future and that of his captain on a knife-edge, which side will Sinclair choose to fight for?

Having read and hugely enjoyed Hemry’s other military science fiction series ‘Stark’ and ‘The Lost Fleet’ I eagerly got stuck into this one. I was not sure what to expect this time with the courtroom, legal angle in outer space but from the pen of Hemry I knew this would be a strong character driven adventure.

In Paul Sinclair we have a believable, fallible ensign who takes the reader into a world that is hectic and extremely stressful and demanding.

The USS Michaelson is not a shiny, flashy spacious spacecraft from the movies, but rather a cramped, uncomfortable and claustrophobic tub. You can sense the crews discomfort as they patrol the outer reaches of space on a patrol that can last for months with the same people and the same routine their only constants.

Typically of Hemry this focuses on the personalities on the ‘Merry Mike’ as the crew christen it. They are a mixed bunch from the slackers and no-hopers to the high achieving and ambitious. The ones that are quick to smile are not always the ones you can trust as Sinclair is quick to discover.

This is what I enjoy about Hemry’s work, he is great at presenting and dissecting different character types, often putting them into a dilemma and letting us see how the drama plays out.

With his own background in the US navy Hemry places his sci fi into the realms of the possible and the plausible. This may be set in the late twenty-first century but naval codes of conduct are still followed to the letter and this is steeped in tradition and chain of command. The book is all the better for it as it gives it that much needed ring of authenticity.

It all builds nicely to a gripping finale in the courtroom where the outcome is uncertain and the stakes are high. For my money Hemry has managed again to provide the reader with an absorbing and intelligent science fiction drama in an all too plausible future. I for one will be keeping a look out for his next novel.

First Published 2003
This Edition 2012 by Titan Books
ISBN: 9780857689405

Review by

Our interview with John G Hemry

John G Hemry (who also writes under the pen name of Jack Campbell) is a retired U.S. Navy officer and author of military science fiction novels. He is best known for his Lost Fleet series, set one-hundred-plus years into an i [...]

Read interview


John G Hemry's JAG In Space series

A Just Determination

JAG In Space: Book 1

Burden of Proof

JAG In Space: Book 2

A Just Determination reader reviews

9/10 from 1 reviews

Write a reader review

There are currently no reader reviews for this book. Why not be the first?

Your rating out of 10

More reviews of John G Hemry books

Books you may also enjoy

Lear's Daughters

Marjorie B Kellogg

Surface Detail

Iain M Banks

Pushing Ice

Alastair Reynolds

Brightness Reef

David Brin

Record of a Spaceborn Few

Becky Chambers

Startide Rising

David Brin


Isaac Asimov

Following reviews

Burden of Proof

John G Hemry


Sean A Tinsley

The Spirit Rebellion

Rachel Aaron

The Order of the Scales

Stephen Deas

The Left Hand of God

Paul Hoffman

Brutal Light

Gary W Olson

Keturah and Lord Death

Martine Leavitt