Sixteen Ways to Defend a Walled City by KJ Parker

(7.7/10) A quick and fun read that tries to be a little different. Recommended for those that prefer books about military strategy rather than those that crave strong fantasy elements.

This was so much fun. I could tell that K.J Parker had a real laugh when writing it. Orhan is a great character, and although he is hilariously out of his depth his keen mind allows him to pull through a rather tricky situation, though not without several awkward blunders. 

Orhan is an engineer, not a military man, and he finds himself leading the defence of a city he doesn’t really care about. He’s got no real experience giving battlefield orders; he’s used to organising men to build bridges and walls not commanding them to defend a city. And he knows about his own shortcomings, but he steps into command because there’s nobody else to do it. He doesn’t want to be in charge, he simply has to or the city will fall and everybody in it will be put the sword. He is forced to act the role of general in an Empire he hates. 

So, it makes for a somewhat unusual situation which only gets more complicated when he learns exactly who is leading the invading army. I shall give no spoilers, but it certainly makes the siege more difficult, a siege that would have been over in a matter of hours had Orhan not taken charge. He is cunning, resourceful and a born liar which gives him a unique skill set. A military man, driven by honour, may not have possessed the savviness to bring a city full of cut-throats to heel. It’s no easy job because Orhan is a white-skin, a second-class citizen, trying to rule over the elite blue-skins that hate his guts. He must get creative to succeed. 

The book is told in the first person and is driven entirely by Orhan’s personality. Both book and protagonist are not afraid of breaking the rules. Orhan admits to being a liar, and he even admits that his story may have been exaggerated. He’s telling it so why not give himself a little bit more glory? Why not make himself sound more dangerous? There’s certainly a streak of unreliable narration running through it giving it an added edge. I could make several guesses over which points were true and which were false, which bespeaks the level of immersion I felt whilst reading. However, this type of writing is a double-edged sword. Without wanting to go into any specific details, I found the ending a little frustrating. It leaves it at a bit of a cliff-hanger as Orhan’s part in the story comes to an end. It would have been good to know what happens after even if it was only a summary paragraph of some sort. But, again, this is trying to be different. I’m pretty sure K.J Parker set out to challenge his readers with those final few paragraphs, though I have come away a little annoyed as I want to know what happens next! It works though, Orhan's personality demands such a selfish action.

All in all, this is a quick and fun read that tries to be a little different. Recommended for those that prefer books about military strategy rather than those that crave strong fantasy elements. 

Many thanks to Orbit for sending me a (surprise) review copy and introducing me to an author I may have otherwise missed. 

Review by

12+

Sixteen Ways to Defend a Walled City reader reviews

from England, UK

The book is a fun, quick read. You can't help liking the lying, cheating, conniving, industrious, resourceful, philandering, teetotal coward that is Orhan. I would recommend this as the sort of book you can get into lying on a beach, commuting to work, bedtime wind-down reading or simply something to curl up with and laugh at for fun. It's a great read and an observation on leadership in challenging environments where vested interests and pig ignorance all conspire against your deep seated and illogical loyalty to those that treat you like chattel. Orhan's end to the tale was ... unexpected, and frustrating in many ways as you come to be invested in him and what happens to the thankless, feuding citizens he's determined to protect beyond the details alluded to and sketched out. This said, there is technically scope for a sequel - I'd love to see something like "Seventeen Ways To Build A Bridge Under Enemy Fire (and have fun doing so)" - If 'K J Parker' is reading this - you can have that title or any derivative therein - just as long as you give us a sequel of Orhan and the Imperial Regiment of Engineers.

8.4/10 from 2 reviews

Write a reader review

Your rating out of 10

More KJ Parker reviews

Downfall of the Gods

by KJ Parker

If you visit the Temple and ask nicely for forgiveness, you might get it - assuming you aren't Lord Archias and you haven't killed the Goddess's favorite musici [...]


Published: 2016

Score: 90

Our rating: 9.0 | 0 positive reader reviews

12+

Shadow

by KJ Parker

A man wakes in the wilderness, amid scattered corpses and inquisitive crows. He has no memory of who he is or how he came to be there. The only clues to his former existenc [...]


Published: 0000

Score: 88

Our rating: 8.8 | 0 positive reader reviews

15+

Books you may also enjoy

The Way of Kings

by Brandon Sanderson

Roshar is a world of stone swept by tempests that shape ecology and civilization. Animals and plants retract; cities are built in shelter. In centuries since ten orders of [...]


Published: 2010

Score: 159

Our rating: 9.8 | 51 positive reader reviews

12+

The Sum of All Men

by David Farland

In the first book of The Runelords, Raj Ahten, the Wolf Lord of Indhopal, uses magic to transform himself into the ultimate warrior: The Sum of All Men. He seeks to bring a [...]


Published: 1998

Score: 91

Our rating: 9.0 | 1 positive reader reviews

12+

Blood Song

by Anthony Ryan

Vaelin Al Sorna's life changes for ever the day his father abandons him at the gates of the Sixth Order, a secretive military arm of the Faith. Together with his fellow [...]


Published: 2013

Score: 92

Our rating: 9.0 | 2 positive reader reviews

12+

Foundryside

by Robert Jackson Bennett

In a city that runs on industrialized magic, a secret war will be fought to overwrite reality itself--the first in a dazzling new fantasy series from City of Stairs&nb [...]


Published: 2018

Score: 89

Our rating: 8.8 | 1 positive reader reviews

12+