The Magicians by Lev Grossman (The Magicians series: Book 1)

(9.0/10) A multifaceted coming of age story that is both bright and beguiling.

Book of the Year 2009 (see all)

Quentin Coldwater’s life is changed forever by an apparently chance encounter when he turns up for his entrance interview to Princeton he finds his interviewer dead – but a strange envelope bearing Quentin’s name leads him down a very different path to any he’d ever imagined.

The envelope, and the mysterious manuscript it contains, leads to a secret world of obsession and privilege, a world of freedom and power and, for a while, it’s a world that seems to answer all Quentin’s desires. But the idyll cannot last – and when it’s finally shattered, Quentin is drawn into something darker and far more dangerous than anything he could ever have expected…

Lev Grossman knows and understands the academic elite. His time spent - and the experiences gained - living and studying at Harvard and Yale have been used to good effect in the creation of an ambitious and compelling urban fantasy titled The Magicians.

On first glance the reader may be forgiven for thinking that this is simply another novel about gifted youngsters attending a school of magic, albeit aimed at a more mature audience. They would be mistaken. The author has taken all that is held dear in the fantasy genre, reverently (most of the time) tipping the hat to Rowling, Tolkien, Lewis, Le Guin and others, and shown it from a completely different and unique angle.

The Magicians is split into four books, all markedly different. Part one mainly deals with the discovery of the magical academy (called Brakebills and hidden to the none-gifted), and the subsequent training in the arts of magic. The second book deals with the difficulties faced by students when their education is over and they are faced with the stark reality that is working life and responsibility. In the third book the fantasy elements take full control as we enter the magical (more so) world of Fillory (think of a Tim Burton realised Narnia). By the beginning of the fourth and final book the reader is completely hooked and Grossman delivers the final flourish with a thrilling climax and an extremely satisfying ending.

The characters that inhabit Grossman’s worlds are flawed and very, very realistic. The thoughts and behaviour of the late teen / early twenty-something’s whose lives we follow are excellently, and sometimes uncomfortably accurate. From the casual alcoholism to the hormone-controlled behaviour, the way these people behave will leave many cringing as they recognise themselves amongst the far-from-perfect ensemble.

The narrative is precise and well constructed as works well with Grossman’s style of characterisation, which is often reminiscent of Stephen King, particularly in the way that Quentin, Eliot, Alice and others gain faces and step lifelike from the page as soon as they are introduced. The author also shows an admirable eye for detail and an obvious talent for human observation.  

The book has many highlights, one of them being the magical school of Brakebills South, situated in Antarctica. The except below describes Quentin’s first impressions of this magical place:

“Stone for stone, board for board, Brakebills South was the same house as the House at Brakebills. Which was reassuring in a way, but it was incongruous to find what looked like an eighteenth-century English country house planted in the middle of a soaring Antarctic wasteland. The roof of the West Tower was broad and round and paved with smooth flagstones, with a stone wall running around the edge. It was open to the elements, but some kind of magical arrangement kept the air warm and humid and protected it from the wind, or mostly. Quentin imagined he could feel a deep chill lurking underneath the warmth somewhere. The air was tepid, but the floor, the furniture, everything he touched was cool and clammy. It was like being in a warm greenhouse in the dead of winter.”
The Magicians: Marie Byrd Land

The Magicians is a book that will likely divide opinions leaving very few sitting on the fence. The majority will love it but there will be some that will detest it (ardent Potter and Narnia fans possibly). The fantasy genre always needs an author to come along a show it in a different light and this is exactly what has Grossman has done. He has injected sexual tension and questionable morals into a school for wizards and the result is a rousing, perceptive and multifaceted coming of age story that is both bright and beguiling. The Magicians is a perfect fantasy book for older teens that will find that the author understands them, and their feelings, possibly better than they do themselves.

Lev Grossman was born in 1969, the son of two English professors, and grew up in a suburb of Boston. He graduated from Harvard with a degree in literature and went on to the Ph.D. program in comparative literature at Yale, although he left after three years without finishing a dissertation.

Review by

5 positive reader review(s) for The Magicians

Our interview with Lev Grossman

Lev Grossman, the son of two English professors, grew up in a suburb of Boston. He graduated from Harvard with a degree in literature and went on to the Ph.D. program in comparative literature at Yale. He worked for a string [...]

Read interview

15+

Lev Grossman's The Magicians series series


The Magicians

The Magicians series: Book 1
9.0/10

The Magician King

The Magicians series: Book 2
8.7/10

The Magician's Land

The Magicians series: Book 3
9.0/10

The Magicians reader reviews

from USA

It was a fascinating read--one can never guess what's coming! However, the entire time I read it I kept wondering what the point of Brakebill's was supposed to be. I mean, what were graduates SUPPOSED to do; what was their purpose in life? Were there any guidance counselors? (Tee hee) Even Liberal Arts graduates usually have some idea as to what they want to do! As these students came to graduation, there seemed to be no place to go. Was there something there I missed?

from USA

Cross between C L Lewis Narnia and J K Rowling Harry Potter.

from Israel

A great book, part of an even better series.

from Michigan

Sometimes Grossman tends to get too caught up in the details, and suddenly switches his focus to something else, making you believe he either gave up on an idea mid-way, or that he suffers from A.D.D. and its apparent even in his finished writing. Aside from this irksome habit, I found this to be a painful, refreshing fantasy novel, that almost destroys it's own place as a fantasy due to how realistic it feels. Forget the petty teen angst Harry Potter and friends face, The Magicians is crammed to the brink with reality; apathy, depression, sex, drugs, alcohol, fumbling for purpose and happiness. I found myself assuming he would take things one direction, and much like life, I found myself hoping or expecting for something much different then what he gave me. This novel is by no means typical to the genre. It's been a week since I finished it, and I still find myself personally tormented by the ending, and waiting extremely impatiently for the sequel.

from Augusta, Georgia

Rarely in the genre do I not know how the book will end. I think you can't have enjoyed any of the best fantasy books and not felt something for this one. It very much brings the whole idea home again, after traveling to all of those far away lands. It was a pleasure.

from US

Best fantasy book all year. Highly recommended.

9.1/10 from 7 reviews

Write a reader review

Your rating out of 10

Books you may also enjoy


Seven Blades in Black

Sam Sykes
9.5/10

The Obsidian Tower

Melissa Caruso
9.5/10

The Limits of Enchantment

Graham Joyce
9.4/10

Silver Mage

CM Debell
9.1/10

Dawn of the Exile

Mitchell Hogan
9.1/10

Storm Front

Jim Butcher
9.0/10

The Autumn Republic

Brian McClellan
9.0/10

The House of Shattered Wings

Aliette de Bodard
9.0/10

Following reviews


Storm Front

Jim Butcher
9.0/10

The Midnight Charter

David Whitley
8.5/10

The Novice

Trudi Canavan
8.1/10

The High Lord

Trudi Canavan
8.6/10

The Hellbound Heart

Clive Barker
8.0/10

The Day of the Dragon

Richard A Knaak
6.6/10

Turn Coat

Jim Butcher
8.5/10

Mirrorstorm

Mike Wilks
6.5/10