The Wilful Princess and the Piebald Prince by Robin Hobb

7/10 Fans of the Elderlings trilogy of trilogies will want to pick this novella up.

Returning to the fictional universe of a favoured author is often fraught with disappointment, much like returning to the playing grounds of your childhood: nothing is quite as you thought; nothing is as enjoyable or perfect.

A few years ago Robin Hobb released the first in a new series of books that I felt were horrible. I could not even finish the first book, and subsequently my entire opinion of her writing was tarnished. I had come to her late – she had already finished all nine of her Elderlings books and had written the Soldier Son trilogy which so many people had disliked – and so to have new material put in front of me only to so dislike it was truly disappointing.

I may need to go back and revisit those books, because having just read her novella ‘The Wilful Princess and the Piebald Prince’ I feel I may have done her an injustice.

Reading Hobb’s original trilogy will reveal to the interested party mention of this tale, a tale passed down through the ages of how a pretender to the throne was thwarted by the rightful heir. Needless to say, history is written by the victors and this novella sets the record straight – as I believe was hinted at throughout Hobb’s original trilogy.

The story is told in two parts: part one is entitled ‘The Wilful Princess’ and is the better of the two, being a traditional first person narrative of events. The second part – ‘The Piebald Prince’ – is told from the perspective of the same narrator, but based mostly on events as told to the narrator by another party, which creates a distressing mode to the story. Throughout much of the tale the narrator continually refers to the desire of the original teller for truth in the retelling, and how that same teller related events to her, and therefore they were true.

It is a device that was not done very well, but could have been excellent if left to the right hands.

Nevertheless the story that is portrayed – a single long story told over two parts – is quite enthralling and kept me entertained right till the end. It was fantastic to return to the world of Buck Keep and the Six Duchies, the Farseer line and the world of Witted and non. It makes me crave for time to reread Hobb’s original trilogy.

If you’re a fan of the Elderlings trilogy of trilogies, then you’ll definitely want to pick this novella up. However, if you’re new to Hobb, I would recommend going back to the beginning, as there is enough to persecute a readers mind as to make it frustrating.

Review by

Our interview with Robin Hobb

City of Dragons, the third instalment in The Rain Wild Chronicles, will be published in the UK on the 23rd of April 2012. In advance of the book's release, Robin Hobb has kindly taken time to expound on the inspirations b [...]

Read interview


The Wilful Princess and the Piebald Prince reader reviews

7/10 from 1 reviews

Write a reader review

There are currently no reader reviews for this book. Why not be the first?

Your rating out of 10

More reviews of Robin Hobb books

Books you may also enjoy

Harrowing the Dragon

Patricia McKillip

The Dragon's Tooth

ND Wilson

The Rage of Dragons

Evan Winter

Tales from the Perilous Realm

JRR Tolkien


Jackie Gamber


Pamela Wiseman and Sarah Laichas


Steven Brust

Flight of the Darkstar Dragon

Benedict Patrick

Following reviews

Without Warning

John Birmingham

Fun to Draw Mini Mangas

T Beaudenon

Falling Kingdoms

Morgan Rhodes

Signal In The Distance

Peter Welmerink

The Tower of Bones

Frank P Ryan

The Three Powers

Frank P Ryan

Shadow Ops series

Myke Cole