Menu

Of Shadow and Sea by Will Wight (The Elder Empire: Shadow Book 1)

9/10 An unique novel in concept, in execution, and in terms of setting. It’s wonderfully engaging, a ton of fun to read

Will Wight gives us a fantastic start to his Elder Empire series in Of Shadow and Sea. This first book represents one of the more unique ways to write a fantasy series. Of Shadow and Sea covers the same events as Wight’s Of Sea and Shadow. But the protagonists in this book are the antagonists in that one, and vice-versa. Even knowing that makes for an interesting and engaging story, and I imagine reading both of the books will provide varying perspectives on all the characters in a truly unique way. But apart from the concept and unique structure of the story, this novel shines all on its own.

There is so much to praise in this start to the Elder Empire series it’s difficult to know exactly where to start. I suppose the first element of the story to jump out at me was the world building. This is one of Wight’s most unique worlds - and that’s saying something coming from an author who typically crafts deep and engaging settings for his stories. The Elders and Elderspawn are interesting and mysterious, and Wight offers details here and there about their nature and origins that are truly tantalizing. There is an island that features in the plot that is entirely covered in skin. As in… not dirt, but skin. It’s creepy and weird and so unique. What’s most important to me, however, is the way the world building draws you into the story. The unique setting is used to great effect in conveying the tale Wight wants to tell and it ends up being more than simply a fun backdrop.

The magic system that exists in this world is another favorite element for me. There are so many layers to the system that are interrelated. We have Soulbound, able to perform certain magics based on their vessel. This is cool on its own, but then there are Readers, individuals able to read an object’s history, understand the object, and inject more intent into it - and do other impressive things to boot. To say more might be spoilery, but the various functions interrelate and make for an exquisitely complex magic system that Wight manages to communicate without ever resorting to paragraphs and paragraphs of exposition. Of course, beyond this world building are the characters. Each of the characters are interesting and feel real and authentic. It’s also fascinating to realize, as you’re reading, that your story’s heroes are another story’s villains, and that villain who you perceive as self-serving is some else’s hero. It’s very meta, and Wight is undoubtedly making a statement about perspective that’s equal parts fun and profound.

There were a couple small things that didn’t connect with me. I sometimes found the characters, both the heroes and the villains, to lack emotional connection for me. Frankly, this might be because I was thinking a little too much about them, rather than just feeling with them. But there were moments when I felt like I should have felt more emotion for them, and I just didn’t. Pacing was another area where things felt a little uneven for me. It wasn’t bad, or slow, but once or twice in the novel I felt like maybe the pacing was just slightly off. It’s possible this is a result of needing the story to line up and maintain adequate pacing across two entirely separate novels.

Of Shadow and Sea is a unique novel in concept, in execution, and in terms of setting. It’s wonderfully engaging, a ton of fun to read, and plays with perspective and who the good guys are in absolutely fascinating ways. A wonderful start to a series, this is one worth grabbing at your next opportunity.

Review by

Will Wight's The Elder Empire series


Of Shadow and Sea

The Elder Empire: Shadow Book 1
9/10

Of Shadow and Sea reader reviews

8.8/10 from 1 reviews

Write a reader review

There are currently no reader reviews for this book. Why not be the first?

Your rating out of 10

More reviews of Will Wight books

Books you may also enjoy


The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms

NK Jemisin
10.0/10

The Raven Tower

Ann Leckie
10.0/10

Nevernight

Jay Kristoff
10.0/10

Touch of Iron

Timandra Whitecastle
10.0/10

A Storm of Swords 1: Steel and Snow

George RR Martin
9.9/10

Legend

David Gemmell
9.8/10

The Priory of the Orange Tree

Samantha Shannon
9.8/10

Holy Sister

Mark Lawrence
9.6/10

Following reviews


The Bard's Blade

Brian D Anderson
9.0/10

Limbo

Thiago DEvecque
7.5/10

Bright Ruin

Vic James
8.5/10

Magnificat

Julian May
8.9/10

The Light of All that Falls

James Islington
9.2/10

Vox Machina Origins

Matthew Mercer
8.0/10

Warrior of the Altaii

Robert Jordan
6.5/10

Embers of War

Gareth L Powell
8.5/10