The Council of Blades by Paul Kidd


Council of Blades is a novel aimed at devotees of the Dungeons and Dragon fantasy role-playing game and the story is set in one of the game’s shared worlds – the Forgotten Realms.

Sumbria is a city state, one of the Blade Kingdom’s many city states, a military society modelled on early renaissance Italy. So is Colletro. The book opens with Sumbria and Colletro facing off against each other, ready to wage bloody war over the Valley of Umbricci but before they come to blows the two sides manage to negotiate a truce which sees Sumbria emerge with the better deal much to Colletro’s chagrin.

MilianaMannicci is an intelligent but plain princess (the book’s blurb, not mine) of Sumbria. She’s our feisty heroine, a budding wizard with a sharp temper and desire for adventure.

Prince UgoSvarezi, a Colletran knight and the villain of the piece, comes to Sumbria to celebrate the truce. During his visit he meets Blade Captain Gilberto Ilego, a Sumbrian nobleman who schemes to increase his power and social standing. Naturally, the two team up to bring about the downfall of Sumbria and realise their ambitions. Svarezi also meets young Lorenzo Utrelli, a prince from Lomatra, another of the Blade Kingdom’s city states.

Lorenzo is an artist, scientist and inventor and his most accomplished creation is a giant laser which he developed for use in mining. Unable to find a sponsor for his devices, in his native Lomatra, Lorenzo tries to find a benefactor in Sumbria and is feted by Ilego and Svarezi who manipulate him and use his machine to help the Colletran army invade Sumbria. Outraged, Lorenzo joins forces with Miliana and Tekoriikii, a kleptomaniac firebird (a cross between a phoenix and a large parrot), to thwart Svarezi’s invasion. 

The verdict
Overall, The Council of blades was an enjoyable romp but there were a couple of major issues with the book. First is the over importance of science and technology in the story and the implication that this is a world against technological innovation and therefore progressive thinking. This is Dungeons and Dragons; it’s not that the world is technophobic, it’s just that technology plays second fiddle to magic given its prevalence in this setting. Yet the message coming across in CoB is the opposite and this would no doubt have grated with Dungeons and Dragons fans. 

And then there’s the humour. There was too much and the story quickly degenerated from humour to parody and slapstick. It’s fair to say, fantasy which takes itself too seriously becomes dull and heavy but, where this book is concerned, Kidd has certainly done himself no favours with Dungeons and Dragons fans. The attention given to science and humour in the book was far too heavy handed and parody of a much loved shared world setting is, by association, insulting to the fans and they will, quite rightly, be turned off by the book. Kidd should have paid more respect the setting and fan base.

Council of Blades was an enjoyable read. Unfortunately, it was horribly over seasoned with humour and science which ultimately spoiled the dish.

Review by


All reviews for Paul Kidd's Forgotten Realms: The Nobles series

The Council of Blades

by Paul Kidd

War cares little for the troubles of the aristocracy. As a terrible new weapon obliterates the age of courtly battle, an intelligent but plain princess and her companions-- [...]

Series: Forgotten Realms: The Nobles #5
Published: 0000

Score: 60

Our rating: 6.0 | positive reader reviews


The Council of Blades reader reviews

6/10 from 1 reviews

Write a reader review

There are currently no reader reviews for this book. Why not be the first?

Your rating out of 10

Books you may also enjoy

Fool's Assassin

by Robin Hobb

Tom Badgerlock has been living peaceably in the manor house at Withywoods with his beloved wife Molly these many years, the estate a reward to his family for loyal service [...]

Series: Fitz and the Fool #1
Published: 2014

Score: 101

Our rating: 9.9 | 2 positive reader reviews


Ship of Magic

by Robin Hobb

On the northernmost point of the Cursed Shores lies Bingtown, a bustling hub of exotic trade and home to a proud merchant nobility famed for its extraordinary vessels. Only [...]

Series: The Liveship Traders: Book 1
Published: 1998

Score: 100

Our rating: 9.7 | 4 positive reader reviews


Harrowing the Dragon

by Patricia McKillip

Spanning a quarter of a century, an anthology of previously uncollected short fiction by the World Fantasy Award-winning author explores a world of magic in such works as & [...]

Series: NA
Published: 2005

Score: 95

Our rating: 9.5 | 0 positive reader reviews


The Dragon's Tooth

by ND Wilson

For two years, Cyrus and Antigone Smith have run a sagging roadside motel with their older brother, Daniel. Nothing ever seems to happen. Then a strange old man with bone t [...]

Series: The Ashtown Burials: Book 1
Published: 2011

Score: 94

Our rating: 9.3 | 1 positive reader reviews